Personally I love the shape of the R lip because you can scrape all over and it wont break due to its design it sorta just bends the bumper rather than lip, the garage vary I feel like would break with half of the stuff I do to my r lip. And on a side note my buddy that has the ebay one looks very flimsy. Im sure alot of people have them on CR and I havnt noticed any looking the same so maybe it was just his.